Bank additional tier 1 (AT1) notes pay a spread above senior bank paper, and for an insurer that spread has to be weighed against risk, capital and liquidity. In this article, written for the actuaries and risk and investment teams that calculate and sign off on insurers' solvency capital requirement (SCR) under South Africa’s Solvency Assessment and Management (SAM) regime, we examine how a South African insurer should treat a bank AT1 note. A second article looks at whether the margin is adequate compensation for the risk and the capital.
For any investor looking for yield above senior bank paper, the spread may be appealing. For an insurer looking to balance return and risk, capita, and liquidity, the calculus is a little more involved. AT1 notes are in reality more heavily subordinated than first-loss-after-capital instruments, have been in issue for longer, and therefore might be a bigger problem for insurers’ balance sheets and the SCR.
This paper includes the following takeaways:
- AT1 notes are perpetual, their coupons can be cancelled, and the principal can be written off if the regulator judges the bank no longer viable.
- The issuing bank treats AT1 notes as equity. For an insurer holding them, they are a credit instrument and belong in SAM spread risk.
- The floating coupon does not make AT1 notes short-dated. For spread risk the duration is about 10 years, and the issuer’s option to call the notes does not shorten it.
- The credit quality step (CQS) should reflect the note, not the bank. Rating agencies put AT1 three to four notches below the bank. Using the bank’s own rating with the SAM standard formula’s loss-given-default adjustment is permitted but cruder, and produces a higher charge.
- For a major South African bank, the standard formula charge is between about 14% and 26% of market value, depending on choices of duration, CQS and whether the adjustment is used.
- Insurers should make those choices deliberately and record them; heck whether pooled funds are carrying AT1 that has not been identified; and put coupon cancellation and write-off into own risk and solvency assessment stresses.